Update: Mythbusting on the Orowaiti cut

Westport Flood Protection Scheme (West Coast Regional Council) responds to ongoing discussion about possible alternatives to structural flood protection.

Why not consider the ‘Orowaiti Cut’ or a direct Cut to the sea from the Orowaiti Estuary?

‍We continually get asked why the ‘overflow’ Cut is not being done or even considered as part of flood protection for Westport. This is basically a suggestion that the sandbank opposite Snodgrass Road is dug out to allow potential flood waters coming from the Orowaiti Lagoon to flow out to sea.

‍This option was put forward for consideration by the Technical Advisory Group that advised Buller Flood Recovery in the immediate post-flood environment (2022). West Coast Regional Council has looked closely at all the advice on this proposed solution. The proposed Cut was suggested as best located where the Orowaiti Estuary bends to the east. The Cut was envisaged as allowing flow to go directly out to the sea, through the spit, thereby preventing higher than wanted ponding of upriver floodwater flows.

‍‍The advice received was that a Cut between the estuary and the current coastline would not be efficient.

Here are some of the factors considered:

Cost. The Cut would have to be very wide to transport enough capacity i.e channel enough water to make a difference. A range of Cuts have been modelled that do show benefit, but the cost was very significant. Advice taken in 2022 is that the cost just to excavate the Cut would be in the region of $5 million.

Gradient. There is a lack of hydraulic gradient to justify a Cut. Simply put, the water levels at the upstream end of the proposed Cut option, are insufficient to enable a fast flow to widen and deepen the Cut efficiently during flood times. Thus, it would have minimal benefit.

Tides. The Buller River has a very large tidal profile, the area gets some very high tides, and the benefits of a Cut are limited during a high tide. The nature of the Buller River floods is that they are often a 24–48-hour floods which means any potential flood would coincide with a high tide.

Silt and sediment. Over and above the cost of putting the Cut in, is the cost of long-term maintenance. The Cut will naturally want to silt back up due to being in a coastal marine area. Maintenance of the Cut would need to be relatively constant due to inevitable silt and sediment build-up and would involve significant ongoing costs.

Coastline growth. The coastline has been growing since the early 1900’s and is expected to continue to do so. This means it would become harder and harder to keep the Cut open over time.

Sea level rise is also expected to continue to increase, further potentially threatening the efficacy of a Cut. According to GNS Science, average sea level to rise is expected to be 3.5 mm per year and Westport is no exception.

Coastal threats. An opening in this area would significantly increase the risk of sea surge and tsunami hazards to residents of Westport. Our experts believe a Cut would enable the propagation of damaging coastal waves through the Lower Orowaiti area during major sea storms.

‍Overall, according to West Coast Regional Council Chief Engineer Peter Blackwood, opening up a Cut at Orowaiti would dangerously expose Snodgrass Road and environs to the full forces of major cyclones and sea storms.

“This area is currently buffered against these impacts by the barrier spit.  It would be a risky business opening up this waterway.”

In summary, a decision was made several years ago, after much debate and discussion, to abandon further investigation for an Orowaiti Cut. WCRC is sticking with this course of action and focusing on structural flood protection for Westport as per the Westport Flood Protection Scheme.

This was run as an Opinion piece in the Westport News on 12 November 2026.

Next
Next

Media Release: Successful tenderer for the lease of Organs Island announced